Repair or replace your furnace?
Last checked: November 2026
Short answer: if a technician has warned you about carbon monoxide or a cracked heat exchanger, stop using the furnace and get it replaced. Otherwise, a common rule of thumb from GTA installers: if your furnace is over 15 years old and the repair costs more than half the price of a new one, replacing it usually makes more sense. Answer the 5 questions below for a plain result.
GTAFurnace.com is a free referral service, not a contractor. Participating contractors pay us a referral fee. These are rules of thumb, not a diagnosis. How we work.
Your result
The rules behind the result
- Safety first. A carbon monoxide or cracked heat exchanger warning means: don't run the furnace, and replace it. On carbon monoxide, follow Enbridge Gas's carbon monoxide safety steps.
- Rule of thumb: the 15-year, 50% rule. GTA installers commonly use it: over 15 years old and a repair that costs more than half the price of a new furnace usually means replacing makes more sense. A two-stage replacement typically costs about $4,000 to $7,000 installed before HST, so half is about $2,000 to $3,500. Source: our furnace cost guide, from GTA contractor price pages.
- Rule of thumb: repeated repairs. More than one repair in 2 years on a furnace that isn't new is a reason to get a replacement price to compare. It doesn't mean you must replace.
- Rule of thumb: rising bills. A higher heating bill on an older furnace is a reason to compare. Enbridge Gas says that if your furnace is over 20 years old, you could be paying close to 32 percent more on your energy bill than you need to. Source: Enbridge Gas: Heating with gas.
Not sure of the age? It's usually on the furnace's rating plate, along with the model and serial number.
Questions
Should I repair or replace my furnace?
A common rule of thumb from GTA installers: if your furnace is over 15 years old and the repair costs more than half the price of a new one, replacing it usually makes more sense. If a technician has warned you about carbon monoxide or a cracked heat exchanger, don't run the furnace, and replace it.
What does half the price of a new furnace mean in the GTA?
Published GTA price pages put most two-stage replacements at about $4,000 to $7,000 installed, before HST. Half of that is about $2,000 to $3,500.
What should I do if my carbon monoxide alarm goes off?
Enbridge Gas says to go outside immediately, call 911 from a safe location, and not go back in until a qualified professional, such as a firefighter, says it's safe.
Is this quiz a diagnosis?
No. It applies rules of thumb to your answers. A TSSA-registered technician has to inspect the furnace to tell you what's wrong with it.
Want a replacement price to compare?
One quote from a TSSA-registered installer. Free for homeowners.